Unabridged: The Book Trends That Are Annoying Us

Y’all know how much I love being a hater and how easily things annoy me, so we’re dedicating a whole episode to the most annoying trends in books these days! I’ve invited Sara Hildreth (Fiction Matters), friend of the pod and one of my favorite book people, to rant with me about secrets, tropes, and the state of literary awards.

 
 

TRANSCRIPT

Traci Thomas 0:00

Hey everybody, it's me, Traci Thomas, host of the Stacks, and you're listening to another episode of the Stacks Unabridged. That is our monthly bonus episode, exclusive to paid subscribers on Patreon and Substack. This month, I have brought my friend, our friend Sara Hildreth, back to talk to me about a trend in books that I find so annoying. I was sending her too many voice memos about it, and finally she was like, "Should we just talk about this in a bonus episode? And I said, "Yeah. Why don't we do that? We also talk about the National Book Award long list, and more importantly, about book awards in general. All right, now it is time for my conversation with Sara Hildreth about annoying book trends and the National Book Awards. Do you remember the year the National Book Award had like all short story collections?

Sara Hildreth 1:00

We had an emergency Zoom in the Fiction Matters community.

Traci Thomas 1:05

Well, that's the year it broke. That's the year it broke. And but also, but also, this year in the lead up to doing all my predictions, I went back and looked through all the long lists, and I got to that list, and then I had to Google what other books came out this year, and there were like real books that came out that year that we all still think and talk about, none of which are the 95 short story collection and debut books, and then that's your Tess Gunty won.

Sara Hildreth 1:30

Oh yeah, like I'm just nobody talks about that book anymore. I never read it.

Traci Thomas 1:33

I never read it. I never want to read it. Just, anyways, okay, we already dived in, people. We're gonna come back and talk about the National Book Award at the end of this conversation. But today I am joined, or we are joined. We're doing a joint episode, so Sara joined by me. I'm joined by Sara.

Sara Hildreth 1:49

That's right. Oh, I forgot I'm going to put this on my feed too.

Traci Thomas 1:52

So if you're a fiction matters person, I I'm Traci. Anyways, that's Sara Hildreth. I'm Traci Thomas. We're gonna talk. Tell them what we're gonna talk about.

Sara Hildreth 2:04

We're gonna talk about. Well, we're gonna talk about 2026 in books. I mean, we're gonna talk about trends, tropes, things that are driving us crazy. I don't know. Maybe we'll get kind of into like books of the year because we will start talking about awards a little bit

Traci Thomas 2:20

but I feel like this came out of this year. You and I have sent a lot of like voice memos and text messages about things that have been annoying us in fiction, and not just 2026, but like sort of like recently.

Sara Hildreth 2:31

Yeah, yeah, I think that's fair because I, I, I have books I want to talk about that have been frustrating me that were not 2026 releases, and yeah, within trends and tropes, I think we really are going to get into like the things that are annoying us in books right now. it's going to be fun.

Traci Thomas 2:47

It's going to be fun, and then at the end, we'll sort of talk about the National Book Award lists. But we're not going to spend too much time because a) by the time you guys hear this, it'll already be like a week in, and b) like the lists are the lists.

Sara Hildreth 3:00

The lists are the lists, but I'm I will be curious. I mean, I haven't read all that many of the National Book Award fiction. Maybe just one. I need to look, but

Traci Thomas 3:11

you didn't read the Valeria Luiselli?

Sara Hildreth 3:12

not yet. I do want to. I it's actually we're reading it in the Fiction Matters community in October, so okay, I will be reading it, but yeah, I I I will be curious, kind of if I read any of those as I read any of those, if they will have any of the things that frustrate me in fiction.

Traci Thomas 3:33

What do we want to start with for things that are pissing us off?

Sara Hildreth 3:35

I think we have to talk about secrets because that's what we have been mostly like voice noting back and forth about recently. I also I listened to you on Sam Sanders's show. You talked a little bit about it, and by the time this comes out, people who listen to my books that matter series will hear me talk about something similar with the author Julie Buntin, who wrote Famous Men which I loved. It's driving me crazy, and it's everywhere.

Traci Thomas 3:59

Okay, tell people what we mean by secrets.

Sara Hildreth 4:09

Okay, so I feel like they're like secrets in fiction can be wonderful, like, and I think that this is partly why they've become a plague because readers love a twist. Even in like literary fiction, I love a late novel reveal that makes you go back and see everything that came before in a new light. That is something that like maybe only books can do in such an effective way, and it's wonderful,

Traci Thomas 4:44

right?

Sara Hildreth 4:45

But I think we have gotten to a place where now we're not just writing secrets in fiction and reveals, but the whole novel becomes driven by the secret. And what I mean by that is like that is the reason the author has given you to keep turning the pages is to find out the secret, and that is what I personally hate in books right now.

Traci Thomas 5:08

I'm gonna add to this a little bit. It's not just that it's what the author has given us to turn the page; it's that the author is literally telling us, "Hey guys, hey guys, my name's Sara Hildreth. Well, actually, that's not my name, but nobody knows my real name. End of chapter. And it's like I don't, I don't need you to tell me that it's the wrong name, especially in a first-person novel, because that's the other thing. It's like, why are you lying to me, the audience. I understand if you're an unreliable narrator, but you wouldn't then tell me that you had a secret because then you, if you're trying to trick me and tell me your name is Sarah Hildreth, then you'd tell me that. But if you're trying to not trick me, why are you confiding in me something where you could just say, "Hey guys, I tell everybody my name's Sara Hildreth, but really it's Traci Thomas. Like that's how you would do it if we were pals, and if not, you just wouldn't tell me. And so the sort of like stringing along, the announcing of the secret is the thing that drives me crazy because I have two options for you: either tell me the truth and make your book work, or or start the book when you're ready to reveal the secret. You don't need to give me 50 pages of all this other stuff, and it's like, by the way, nobody still nobody knows my real name. Like, okay, okay, great, cut there and pick up with. I'm finally ready to tell people my real name. I've been keeping the secret for 45 years. Like, I just it is, it's cheap and it's bad writing.

Sara Hildreth 6:41

Okay, there are so many. I feel like it brings up so many issues because, so the dangling of the secret thing. Number one, it it reveals that you don't have enough plot in the present timeline to keep the reader engaged. It makes me wonder if this secret is so interesting, why aren't you writing a novel about that story? Like, why? If I'm supposed to care so much about what has already happened in the past, like maybe that's actually

Traci Thomas 7:13

the story.

Sara Hildreth 7:14

The story. Yes. Why am I not reading that? The first person thing, like you said, like the lying to the the reader, or just like the obfuscating, and and it makes you aware of the craft. It breaks the suspension of disbelief because you see the author behind the narrator choosing what not to tell you. the The book that really revealed this for me, and I'm totally fine naming names here because this book was huge, and I actually I liked her other books, and she's very successful. But it was Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaghy.

Traci Thomas 7:56

I didn't read that.

Sara Hildreth 7:56

Do you remember that book last year? Yeah it it had the like stormy cover.

Traci Thomas 7:58

It had the cover that everybody had last year.

Sara Hildreth 8:00

With like the like painting, exactly storm with the like bright front, yeah. And it was not only was it in first person; it was in first person present tense. Okay, so so that means we are in the narrator's head in the exact moment that they're thinking every thought,

Traci Thomas 8:23

yeah.

Sara Hildreth 8:24

So it makes zero sense that they would be like withholding information. There was literally a scene where a character was cleaning blood off the floor and being like, "And I think about what happened here. End of chapter. It's like that.

Traci Thomas 8:41

That's insane.

Sara Hildreth 8:41

So lazy. That is insane. It's so annoying, and the other thing that, as just as a reader who likes more complexity in my books, that drives me crazy is one of the things this book, this type of book, does is it boils things down as if one thing, one piece of backstory explains it all.

Traci Thomas 9:06

Yes,

Sara Hildreth 9:07

it's like this key that unlocks everything about the character, and that's just kind of boring too.

Traci Thomas 9:13

It's so boring, and I feel like for people listening who are like, "Well, what would you want them to do if there's a secret? I actually don't want you to tell me there's a secret. I want you to reveal the secret to me. So, like for example, this is a bit of a spoiler for Gone Girl, but the book's been out for a while. But the book is happening. We're we're with Ben Affleck's character. We're like, where's Amy? Where I don't remember his name. I just remember her name was Amy. Where's Amy? What's going on at the end of part one, and here's a spoiler: we flip to part two. Spoiler, spoiler, spoiler! Amy is like you guys. I did it. There is no part during part one where he's like, "I wonder if Amy's still alive out there. It would make total sense that she could. Still be out there. It's like no, you don't have to do that. You don't have to do that. We could just go with you, and you could just lie to us. Like you could just lie to us. You could just withhold information from us and then tell us later. Sara, you mentioned a book to me that you really liked. I can't remember the title, but like the first part of the book, you follow a woman and she's like has her everyday life, and then like start chapter three, or at the end of chapter two, she's like gets a phone call, and she's like, "Oh, sorry, I have to take this phone call. And then you start chapter three, and she's like in a hotel room with her lover.

Sara Hildreth 10:30

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 10:31

she doesn't say to us, "I'm talking to the pizza guy. Just kidding. My husband has no idea who I'm talking to. It's a total secret. Like I don't need to know. You don't need to dangle a secret. I want you to have a secret. I want you to manipulate me with that secret. I want you to surprise me, wow me, dazzle me. But I at no point want you to tell me it's a secret unless the secret is important to the story and not a secret from me. Do you know what I mean?

Sara Hildreth 10:59

Yes.

Traci Thomas 11:00

So like, yes, for people who know me, you know I love Shakespeare. One of the things I love about Shakespeare is that Shakespeare's characters, for 99% of the time, they do not lie. There is no such thing as subtext in Shakespeare. Sorry, English teachers, but you-you've been lied to.

Sara Hildreth 11:17

You're apologizing directly to me.

Traci Thomas 11:19

To you and and your ilk, okay? There's no subtext in Shakespeare, and the only character that I know for sure lies, and there might be one or two other, is Iago. Every other character who tells a lie on stage to another character, which is rare, they tell us first. They say, "I'm gonna go lie to Sara right now. Watch this. Watch how I ruin Sara's life with this lie. Next scene, me and Sara talking. Right? I'm lying to you, but the audience knows we can know a secret. We can know a lie. Like that's okay. It's that I don't want you to tell me I'm gonna go tell Sara a secret and then not go tell Sarah's secret. Yeah, make me wait for two acts. Shakespeare would never.

Sara Hildreth 12:05

Yeah, it it is so strange. I just and I one of the reasons I wanted to talk about this with you is I don't know if we'll be able to get to the bottom of this, but like, why is this happening? Where did it start? Why are they doing this to us? I mean, I I do think that like how popular thrillers are is part of it. There's like oh, people love a twist. Like that's that's part of it. But again, we are not anti twist. We are not anti reveal. We are anti dangling the reveal. We are anti secret when it makes no sense that the narrator would keep the secret

Traci Thomas 12:44

and I'm not even I'm not even anti like I have to solve this problem, and it's like I think I know what I'm gonna do. I don't mind that,

Sara Hildreth 12:50

yeah.

Traci Thomas 12:51

I don't mind. I don't mind.

Sara Hildreth 12:53

There can be a delay.

Traci Thomas 12:54

Yes, and there, but it's not like I just don't like being manipulated in the way where it's like you have this thing that you know, and there's no reason I don't know it except for that you won't tell me. Do you know what I mean? Yes. Like I, I don't know if that makes sense to other people like listening, and I don't mind if you lie to other people. I love when you lie to other people, actually. Anyway, sorry, I interrupted you. So, what's your theory?

Sara Hildreth 13:20

No, no, it, it just it it's so strange. Like I I just read Understory, which I also had other issues with. It's not, which I texted you about. Thank you for letting me.

Traci Thomas 13:30

Like I've told everyone I know about this. Like literally, people. I'm like, there's. Do you want to hear the craziest thing that's in a book this year?

Sara Hildreth 13:40

Um. Anyways, they're like this is on the back cover. I, I think I'm just gonna say it. I'm pretty sure it's on the back cover. You gave me your copy. You're looking around for yours.

Traci Thomas 13:52

They sent me another one. No, they sent me another one.

Sara Hildreth 13:57

It's not on the back cover, so I will not spoil it. But the main character is dealing with like she's she's gotten a divorce, she's dealing with like some some grief, some issues, and it's not it's not first person, but it's close third in the way where it's still so, and to me, it was obvious what had happened. Like I'm probably telling you this, and you're like, okay, I know what happened. Yeah, like you're, and you're right because it's such a trope now. But like, there's no point to keep withholding it for you know 100 pages or whatever it is in this book. So yes, I completely agree. It's often the dangling of a secret. This book doesn't say like she had a secret, blah blah blah. Like, but there are just times when you recognize as a reader, you just have this moment of the author is keeping something from me just for the sake of keeping it from me, and I, I, I understand that. This kind of these decisions are hard because everything about a novel, right, is deciding when you're going to reveal certain information. But I do think we have gotten to a point where people are way too much leaning into the withholding, and but because they're withholding so much, there are also these like little sprinkles of like, don't worry, I am going to tell you something that has happened, and I hate that too.

Traci Thomas 15:26

Okay, wait. Before you get to your theory about why, or your our theories about why, can I ask you, as an English teacher, after just shitting on your people, what are past books? They don't have to be classics, but just like deep backlist where you can remember there being like major twists or secrets. Like I'm trying to think. Like to kill a mockingbird, pretty straightforward, right? Like Great Gatsby. There's no big twist there. Like I'm just trying to think of like who's done a twist well in the past.

Sara Hildreth 15:58

I mean, I think the biggest one that is like the most classic and furthest back is Jane Eyre.

Traci Thomas 16:07

There's a twist in that? I've read Jane Eyre. I don't remember a single. I just remember being bored. I'm sorry.

Sara Hildreth 16:12

But you always confuse Jane Eyre and Jane Austen? Which one did you read?

Traci Thomas 16:17

Well, I did. I think I read Jane Eyre and Pride and Prejudice. Are these by different people?

Sara Hildreth 16:21

Yes, Jane Eyre is by Charlotte Bronte. Okay, I'm gonna spoil Jane Eyre. Skip ahead.

Traci Thomas 16:26

How dare you?

Sara Hildreth 16:27

Okay, if you don't want to know the fact that he's keeping his wife in the attic.

Traci Thomas 16:32

I didn't read Jane Eyre.

Sara Hildreth 16:34

Oh my god! I just spoiled Jane Eyre for you.

Traci Thomas 16:37

I ain't read no damn wife in the attic. Okay, okay.

Sara Hildreth 16:40

What? Okay. Well, can I tell you about it now?

Traci Thomas 16:43

I mean, you've ruined it all.

Sara Hildreth 16:44

The way that she's she builds it is so Jane is a governess in this house, okay, and she's taking care of this little girl. And but always when she's in her bedroom, she hears like these this like thumping upstairs, and she has like a weird relationship with one of the other servants named Grace Poole, and she's like, "This Grace must be like an alcoholic, and like I'm scared of her, and like all of this stuff builds. Then weird things start happening, like some like somebody's creeping into Jane's room, and she's like, "What the fuck is happening? In the meantime, she starts to develop feelings for mr. Rochester, who is her employer.

Traci Thomas 17:24

Wow, I've never read this. This, these are all my names for me. Okay, I've had this and Pride and Prejudice confused. I guess my whole life. This is incredible. Okay, they're so different. Okay, so Pride and Prejudice is the sisters?

Sara Hildreth 17:37

Yeah.

Traci Thomas 17:37

Okay, I read that the Bennets or whatever the fuck.

Sara Hildreth 17:42

Um. and so mr. Rochester proposes to her.

Traci Thomas 17:47

Okay,

Sara Hildreth 17:48

and when they are at their wedding day, this guy comes in and is like, "He can't marry you. He's married to my sister,

Traci Thomas 17:56

Mr. Darcy, how dare you?

Sara Hildreth 18:00

The wife, Bertha Mason, has gone insane, and he's been keeping her in locked in the attic for years.

Traci Thomas 18:09

Wow, that is a twist. Well, now I never have to read this, but I'm I'm kind of sad I didn't.

Sara Hildreth 18:16

It's it's pretty good. Maybe wait 10 years, you'll forget.

Traci Thomas 18:19

I definitely will forget.

Sara Hildreth 18:20

Think about that. But I mean that that's like a true twist, and we are in Jane's first person perspective. She is limited by what she knows, and it's it's the great kind of twist where when you go back and reread it, you're like, oh yes, there are like all of these little clues,

Traci Thomas 18:36

Right. But she's not keeping us the secret from us?

Sara Hildreth 18:41

She is not keeping the secret.

Traci Thomas 18:43

I see.

Sara Hildreth 18:44

The secret is being kept from her, and I think that is crucial. Then there's another book which I'm not going to spoil for you this time, called Rebecca.

Traci Thomas 18:52

Oh yeah

Sara Hildreth 18:52

By Daphne Du Maurier. Have you heard of it?

Traci Thomas 18:53

I've heard of it, but I've never read it.

Sara Hildreth 18:55

So this is actually basically Jane Eyre fan fiction. Okay, but the twist is totally different.

Traci Thomas 19:02

And is the is the character who's involved in the twist keeping the twist from us?

Sara Hildreth 19:07

Well, yes, because she is telling the story backwards. The story begins at the end, and she tells it backwards.

Traci Thomas 19:09

Got it.

Sara Hildreth 19:15

But we don't feel like she's revealing information as she would have gotten it at the got it at the time, so yeah. So I mean, I think that like the like best twists, the best secrets are when the narrator is in the dark, and of course that is still the author withholding information from us, but they have chosen the narrator.

Traci Thomas 19:42

It's when the one who has the secret and they're keeping the secret. I think that's the issue because I'm thinking, like for example, this is slightly different. I'm thinking of Lolita, and that is like an unreliable narrator, and he's keeping a lot of secrets from us. He just doesn't tell us their secret. Like he's just like not giving us information. He's not saying I have one

Sara Hildreth 20:02

He trying to manipulate us.

Traci Thomas 20:03

Yes, but he's not doing it by being like

Sara Hildreth 20:06

I'm manipulating you.

Traci Thomas 20:07

Yes, he's not telling us. He's trying. His whole thing. It's a long con. It's a long con. There's no. There is no twist. I guess in that book, but there is this unreliable narrator who's talking to us, who is telling us things, and he, but he never at any point says, "I'm not telling you the full story here."

Sara Hildreth 20:28

Right,

Traci Thomas 20:28

right. That's the thing I hate. I want you to lie to me. If that's what you need to do, first person narrator to tell your story. If you have to lie to me, that is fine.

Sara Hildreth 20:38

Yeah. Well, I mean, and like to go back to your your you know, my name's not really Sara Hildreth. Example, I feel like one of the like greatest opening lines, and I'm not advocating for anyone to necessarily go and read this book, is Moby Dick. Call me Ishmael because just by saying call me Ishmael, you're like you don't know if that's the person's real name.

Traci Thomas 21:00

Am I calling you Ishmael because that's your name, or am I calling you Ishmael because that's what I have to call you because the feds are after you?

Sara Hildreth 21:06

Right, and it just is you know three little words that sets up a question of like how reliable is this narrator?

Traci Thomas 21:12

Is that an unreliable narrator book?

Sara Hildreth 21:14

Well, there's not a twist. It's not like oh,

Traci Thomas 21:17

I know that. I know it's boring, but like, is is Ishmael unreliable?

Sara Hildreth 21:22

I mean, personally, I think every first-person narrative is unreliable. So, in that sense, I feel like Moby Dick is playing with the idea of like, what can one person who's like lowly on this ship really know and understand about power and the decisions being made? So it's a like missing information, and I think that like line has been debated for so long because it could just be that his name is Ishmael, and that's just how he introduces himself. And other people are like, no, this sets up this whole question of who this person i

Traci Thomas 21:53

Interesting. Yeah, I'm thinking of other like sort of twisty backlist books. Like I feel like Handmaid's Tale sort of falls in that category, like, but that's more just like we don't have the information. But she's not, but she knows it, right? It's her perspective. What's her name? Astrid. What's her name?

Sara Hildreth 22:10

Alfred.

Traci Thomas 22:11

Offred.

Sara Hildreth 22:12

Yeah.

Traci Thomas 22:14

She knows the information, and she's slow playing us, but she's also discovering information as she goes.

Sara Hildreth 22:20

Yes. Well, and like I know you hated the the epilogue. I love the epilogue.

Traci Thomas 22:25

I hate the epilogue, but I can't remember why now. Honestly, I'm still thinking about that lady in the attic. I'm gonna. I'm just like really shaken. I thought I read Jane Eyre. I've never read Jane Eyre.

Sara Hildreth 22:37

Oh well. Okay. Well, I mean, and gosh, Jane Eyre is so good because there's so much scholarship too. Because, well, and have you heard of the book Wide Sargasso Sea?

Traci Thomas 22:47

I have

Sara Hildreth 22:47

by Jean Reese. So it's a retelling of Jane Eyre from the wife's from perspective.

Traci Thomas 22:53

Oh my god!

Sara Hildreth 22:54

and Bertha is from the Caribbean.

Traci Thomas 22:59

Okay, I thought that book was about a black person. Got it.

Sara Hildreth 23:02

So there is like you know a lot of readings of Jane Eyre are like about like oh this is a book about like preserving whiteness and he has this black wife in the attic and you got to read it.

Traci Thomas 23:16

I got to wait 10 years now because I know where Bertha's up to. The more you talk about it, the more I'm going to remember. Okay, so when do we think this shift happened? I blame Gone Girl for almost every shift in literature because I feel like it like really like I also blame it for everybody writing in first person.

Sara Hildreth 23:34

Yeah, yeah.

Traci Thomas 23:35

But I'm sure there's other thing, other books.

Sara Hildreth 23:37

Well, Gone Girl came before this, but I also blame Taylor Jenkins Reid.

Traci Thomas 23:42

Oh, I never read that. Do all her books have a secret?

Sara Hildreth 23:44

Of her books, have a secret. They have cliffhangers. They have multiple.

Traci Thomas 23:49

But does she tell you I have a secret?

Sara Hildreth 23:51

Yes.

Traci Thomas 23:52

Okay.

Sara Hildreth 23:53

Maybe not in every book, but in the Evelyn Hugo one.

Traci Thomas 23:57

Yeah.

Sara Hildreth 23:58

Like the whole thing is like the woman Evelyn Hugo, has this reporter come and is like, "I'm gonna, I'm going to tell you my true life story that nobody knows, and it's a secret. And like, slowly drags it out, and then there's even another secret at the end that's revealed. It's like all secrets all the way down.

Traci Thomas 24:20

I feel like there are even books that I actually really like that do this. Like this year, I really like the Shannon Sanders book, but she does a ton of it. Those those ghosts were not forthcoming.

Sara Hildreth 24:32

I I feel like again a lot. Some of this is just choosing the right narrator. Like for those gossipy ghosts, somehow it just made sense, like because they were.

Traci Thomas 24:44

It made sense the first time, but it happens like four times before we even start to get the story to unfold.

Sara Hildreth 24:50

Yes, that's fair. That's it. Was she didn't need to dangle it

Traci Thomas 24:54

for a long or as much.

Sara Hildreth 24:56

But I do feel like there's just this kind of conceit. That you're buying into with like, oh, these ghosts are telling me this story, and they are being withholding because, like, they have my attention, and that's who you know.

Traci Thomas 25:11

Yeah, I'm with you. I feel like it didn't, it didn't piss me off, but I did notice it. I do feel like I sent you a voice memo being like, I need someone to tell me what's going on here? Like, I'm starting. Like, I was like, it's getting. I'm getting close to being mad at people or ghosts, but it did work. Like, I really liked that book.

Sara Hildreth 25:29

Yeah.

Traci Thomas 25:29

So it can sort of work, but at this point, even if it works, I'm noticing. I notice it. I'm like, what? Why are you doing this to me? Why do we think people are doing this to us? Who's doing this and why? Y

Sara Hildreth 25:44

I do think it's like some of it is these big popular books that have had that element. Yeah, and I think I do wonder if like the way people like talk about books on on Booktok and on Bookstagram, there is this like, oh my God, you'll never believe, like kind of discourse that then

Traci Thomas 26:07

But why would you put that in the book? Let me say that about your book. You know,

Sara Hildreth 26:13

I know

Traci Thomas 26:13

that's what I don't understand. Like, was it? Did it happen in the Liz Moore into the God of the woods,

Sara Hildreth 26:21

I don't think so. I think she just surprised us with the

Traci Thomas 26:24

yeah. Well, I know there was like there was some stuff she kind of was like alluding to. I guess it didn't really bother me. It was like oh, when this happened back in 1962. Yeah. Um. And there are like, and it's different than just like a cliffhanger at the end of a chapter. I like that too.

Sara Hildreth 26:38

Yes. Yeah.

Traci Thomas 26:40

Yeah. I will. I think one of my theories is that it has to do with like the second screenification of reading, where it's like I have to remind you I have a secret because you guys are illiterate. You might have can't pay attention, and you you're reading this book over six months. So just reminding you that my name isn't actually Sara again for the fourth time.

Sara Hildreth 26:58

Yeah, I mean I do think I mean some of these books, I do think it's like they don't have enough plot going on in the actual present timeline. So they're reminding you like that something's coming, something big is coming. I also have told you that I blame This Is Us, the TV show?

Traci Thomas 27:21

Oh yeah, because they do

Sara Hildreth 27:23

every fucking week it was like, how did the dad die? We don't know. We're not talking about it, but all of these people know. Everybody knows about you about it.

Traci Thomas 27:34

Person at home on your couch, you're the fucking idiot. You don't know anything about these people. But okay, that's my other part. This is what I meant to say. This is the other thing that annoys me about it. Any time you enter a work of fiction, from wherever the work starts, you, the viewer, reader, consumer, know nothing of these people. There is no, you have no relationship to them whatsoever. This is brand new. I don't need you to tell me you have a secret because I am bought into the story, and everything about you is already a secret to me. You are a new person. This is a new world,

Sara Hildreth 28:15

right?

Traci Thomas 28:15

You can say to me, "Our dad died, and I'm instantly going to go. I wonder what happened.

Sara Hildreth 28:21

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 28:22

you don't need to then say to me 500 times. Bet you want to know how our dad died. I do. I don't know you guys. I want to know everything about you. I want to know your favorite color. I want to know, like, I, I just, I already want to know. I'm here. I'm consuming the thing. This is about how a dad died. I want to know. I also want to know why you have a black brother. I'm curious how Sterling K. Brown ended up here with Mandy Moore and a dead dad. Like, I'm curious why Mandy Moore has on so much makeup. But like, I don't need you to to say to me, "There's a story about how our brother was black. It's like, no shit, babe.

Sara Hildreth 28:58

That's why I'm here. That's why I'm here.

Traci Thomas 28:59

I see that he's black. I I already asked the question. I asked the question before you. I said, "Is that their brother? Wait, who's he supposed to be? Like, so the reiterating of the sort of obviousness. I don't know anything. I'm new to this story, so everything is a question to me. I'm figuring it out as I go along. You don't have to then say to me, "I bet you're wondering about this. I am because I'm I'm reading the story. Isn't that what you want me to do? Because everything that you offer me is the only thing I have.

Sara Hildreth 29:28

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 29:29

I don't know what color the shirt is that you're wearing unless you say I'm wearing a blue shirt. Yeah. So if you choose not to tell me about the shirt, I'm probably not even going to think about it. I'm going to think about whatever you're talking about.

Sara Hildreth 29:40

Yeah. Okay. So a book that I read recently that I actually I didn't really like, but but did something interesting in this regard was Whistler by Ann Patchett.

Traci Thomas 29:52

Okay,

Sara Hildreth 29:53

and

Traci Thomas 29:54

definitely haven't read that. I know that's it's not Pride and Prejudice. Okay,

Sara Hildreth 29:59

there were o wives in attics. She, so it's about a woman who's like in her 50s who reconnects with a man who was her stepfather for like a year or two when she was nine or 10.

Traci Thomas 30:16

Okay,

Sara Hildreth 30:17

so and like the way she introduces the questions is usually through dialog instead of like, and I wondered why did our my mom break up with him? Like it was like she and her sister were talking. They're like, well, do we ever really know like exactly what happened? And like that makes sense to do it through dialog.

Traci Thomas 30:39

So much sense,

Sara Hildreth 30:41

and then she actually just answers the question as soon as it makes sense to answer the question. Like the next time she's with the guy, they talk, and she learns something. It's not like it's hanging over the entire book. And I think that part of it is just like Anne Patchett trusts herself as a writer, where she's just like, I don't need to do like I trust that the reader's going to want to follow this story, and I think that there might be an issue of like self confidence sometimes with these dangling.

Traci Thomas 31:14

Okay, so this is another theory I have that is related but separate, and okay, another book that I read this year that we both read, that we both love, that is arguably the book of the year, is The Disappearers by Marlon James.

Sara Hildreth 31:25

Oh, you mean the book of the century?

Traci Thomas 31:27

The book of the book of Dwight Garner's entire life and the future of civilization. Ever heard of the Odyssey? No, it's out. Emily Emily Wilson, you're out. Get to translating, bitch. We got a new book. One of the things that Marlon James does in the book that I noticed as a reader, and then when I interviewed him, he explicitly said, which is tied to this, is it's not just his confidence; it's that someone like Ann Patchett or someone like Marlon James has confidence in their reader. They have an audience that they know. They have been around long enough to have built their own following. They have a style. I've never read Ann Patchett, but from that horse on that cover, I can tell you who she's writing to.

Sara Hildreth 32:13

Yeah, you know. Although I, I must say, I actually don't think she has all that much confidence in her reader because she does state like very explicitly multiple times. This is what I want you to get out of this novel.

Traci Thomas 32:22

Well, but I don't think she's writing. She's not writing books like Marlon James. That's very on purpose. Like her audience, her reader, she writes to them. She knows who they are. They know who she is. Whatever. And in Marlon James's case, he is more on the Toni Morrison side. I mean, Toni Morrison is a great example. She has a confidence in her reader, and she's just like, if you miss this piece of information, I will bring it up later, but in a totally different way. And you might have to figure out that that thing that I said about the color yellow in chapter one is about this other thing. Like these are the same things, and you just missed it. And I feel like when you have confidence in your reader, you don't have to say, "Hey, hey, hey! Look here, look here! It's a secret. You can just say whatever the fuck you want and let it play out. And I feel like part of what was so thrilling reading the disappearers for me this year is that through the other fiction I've been reading, I was like, "Oh, he's not doing any of that shit that was annoying me. That I was feeling like had to happen because that's just what fiction is these days. He sort of reminded me as a reader of like, no, no, I'm being spoken down to in some regard, right? Yeah,

Sara Hildreth 33:31

yes, yeah. And I, I do think

Traci Thomas 33:34

and that book is full of secrets.

Sara Hildreth 33:36

Yes, yeah. The

Traci Thomas 33:37

whole book is a secret. Every fucking page, you're like, oh wait, what? Wait, hold on. Let me go back. Who said that? Like, the whole time I was reading, I was referring to the list of characters. There were literally certain pages that I knew exactly where they were because I kept referring back to them. Like the last section of part two, the last section of part one. There's a part in the middle of part like three. Like there's so many different parts that I kept going back to, being like, "This is like the turning point in the book. These are the turning points. These are the moments.

Sara Hildreth 34:06

Yes. Well, I okay. As you were talking, I was wondering, like, are authors kind of right not to trust us sometimes? Like are we getting dumber. Yeah. Um. But the other thing is that, I mean, I feel like still everybody has those reading experiences where even even if even people who really like the books that kind of bring them along and they're entertaining and they're not too hard of a work, I feel like have those books where they had to figure something out, and those are the most memorable books because when you have to figure something out, whether that's like you solved the mystery or you interpreted the the line in a way that was meaningful to you, it the reading experience really becomes part of you, yes, and you become part of the book in a way. That is much more meaningful and memorable than when you just get spoon-fed the the answers,

Traci Thomas 35:08

right,

Sara Hildreth 35:08

or the secrets, right, right. And so, I I think yes, writers need to trust readers more, and then also like let us have that we want to like have the experience of getting to make meaning with you,

Traci Thomas 35:25

right? And even like people or myself, like when I read a book that's like I don't know, like because Marlon James is like pretty challenging. Even when I read like a book that is less challenging, that is like more spoon feedy, I still don't want that, you know. Like, I mean, one of my, as you all know, one of my favorite books is the Hunger Games series, and that's for young readers, right? Like, that is a book where there is some element of like readers might not be trained to understand how to read like this, so like I have to tell you things, but there's still not a lot of spoon feeding happening, right? Like, yeah, it it might not be as complicated. There might be like more reminders, but this whole thing of like flagging information 700 times before giving it to to the reader is that's the thing that I hate. And like I think that's like part of the reason sometimes when I'm reading like a thriller or a romance that I get annoyed because I feel like it happens a lot in genre, and that might just be like the style of genre. But I don't need you to like, like I don't know. I just I don't need you to remind me. We still don't. We still don't know who killed Michelle. Like I know, right? I still don't know. I'm assuming that you're gonna tell me at the end because it's a mystery. So you don't have to remind me. Like we're still and my I have a headache, and I'm still trying to figure out who did this horrible thing. It's like, yeah, so am I, the reader over here reading the book still.

Sara Hildreth 36:49

I, I'm glad you brought up romance too, because I do think that that is like genre tropes can work so well in their genres, and then bringing them into contemporary fiction can sometimes cause these these issues. I think romance also is like very, and I've actually heard avid romance readers complaining about this. How so much romance is exclusively first person?

Traci Thomas 37:19

Yeah,

Sara Hildreth 37:19

first person alternating chapters. You go back and forth, and it's just there are some romance readers who I think who will only read first person, and that's why writers do it. But I've I've heard a lot of complaints about that from people who love the genre as well, and I I think that in those cases there sometimes are secrets, like you know the character has something in their past, yeah, that they have to overcome, and and it doesn't make sense to reveal it to us until they reveal it to you know the the

Traci Thomas 37:51

right

Sara Hildreth 37:51

potential romantic partner, but I I do wonder if because you know sales are up in those that people are bringing them into to more literary work, or if it's just like that's what people are reading, and therefore it just

Traci Thomas 38:10

yeah

Sara Hildreth 38:10

naturally you know comes into their own work. I I don't know. I would I would love to talk to like more creative writing instructors about

Traci Thomas 38:21

and editors

Sara Hildreth 38:23

and editors. Yeah.

Traci Thomas 38:24

Do you know what it reminds me of? Do you ever watch The Bachelor?

Sara Hildreth 38:28

No. Well, you know what? I used to watch the the final episode every single year because they tell you everything you need to know.

Traci Thomas 38:37

It's true. Well, so one of the things that happens on the bat happened on The Bachelor a lot. I don't watch anymore, but I used to watch a lot. Is that there would always be like some, if if it was The Bachelor, some girl who was you know one of the contestants who had like a traumatic life story, and she would have a one-on-one date, and she would always be really nervous. Like I don't know if he's gonna still like me after I tell him the truth of my family or whatever, and they would like play it up, play it up, commercial break this. How will I tell him? I'm so nervous for dinner, and then they sit them down at dinner, and then she tells him, and then he gives her the rose and is like, "Thank you so much for sharing this with me. And I feel like that happens so much in romance, where it's like I just that what I don't need is the buildup. You can say we're going on the one-on-one date. I'm super nervous to talk to him, like and tell him more about my family. Commercial break, fine. I'm fine. End of chapter, right? But when I come back, you got to tell him. You got to tell him. You can't give me three segments where you're nervous about this thing because, again, I don't know what the thing is. So if you want to dangle it, you have to tell me what it is, and then you can build on the nervousness. You can even tell me why you think he's not going to like. And then the suspense becomes about what happens when you actually tell him. Then that scene becomes meaningful,

Sara Hildreth 40:07

yeah.

Traci Thomas 40:07

In my opinion,

Sara Hildreth 40:09

Yeah, I I do wonder with hearing you say that. I do wonder if TV is a lot of like really a big influence on this being an issue in in fiction.

Traci Thomas 40:24

Yeah,

Sara Hildreth 40:25

I I think Brandon Taylor has written some not about secrets, but some interesting pieces about like how he can see in his students' writing, like how it's gotten more and more influenced by TV, and how they often want to write from first person, but they're still like looking at the character, so they're like writing in first person, and like you know, you know, my face made a grimace, and it's like okay, you're not seeing that. You wouldn't. So like, like I I wonder if because people consume more TV than writing, we see this kind of

Traci Thomas 41:08

and TV feels so much like first person with reality because you're getting the like the like testimonials, even though it's still third person. So like people's brains aren't fully able to like comprehend that you're actually just in close third, not even that close, because it's like the person is still self-selecting what they say.

Sara Hildreth 41:30

So I think we figured it out. We can blame Gone Girl, Gone Girl, Taylor Jenkins Reid, This Is Us, and reality television.

Traci Thomas 41:38

Perfect. Okay, moving on. Let's talk about the National Book Award long lists. They came out this week as we're recording. Last week as you're listening. What do you think?

Sara Hildreth 41:53

I, I mean, it's always. I always feel like I have to caveat my opinion when I've only read like one of the books with I've only read one of the books, yeah. But I, I didn't. This list didn't make me excited, and I think that I was so curious what would happen this year because there were so many heavy hitters coming out with books, yeah. And I was like, are they going to choose all big names and like have them like battle it out for the National Book Award, or are they going to go totally under the radar? And they kind of went half and half, but like in the in a not very interesting in like the way, yeah,

Traci Thomas 42:33

yeah. So I am a book person, as are you. This is our job. This is a huge part of our lives, and one of the things that I feel sad in my heart about about being a book person is like people are illiterate, and book sales are down, and people don't read, and book bans, and all of these sort of like negative things that we hear about books in the news that makes me sad, and I love books, and I want people to read books. And one of my favorite things about books, and like every industry, I'm also a former theater person, also a dying industry, and like the Tony Awards, so important to me. My whole life so important to me. When I was in high school before I ever lived in New York, the one of the most important nights of my life. When I moved to New York, would see all the shows, knew all about them, and then now I get to watch and like see my friends and like be like, oh, I wish I could see that. And I want books to have this. And the National Book Award has sort of positioned themselves as the Oscars of books, except in the fact that they do not want to actually embrace what it means to be the main award show. Like they are so resistant to celebrating anything that people like, that readers like. And this year, I think, you know, I I've not read a lot of the books, and a lot of these books could be great, and that is wonderful. And yet, still, the snubs of some of the big name authors, some of the best that we have in books right now, that people are excited about, and not just book people, but people who are casual readers, or maybe people who read, you know, two or three books a year. A lot of people who read, who are going to read five books this year, are going to read Kin.

Sara Hildreth 44:30

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 44:31

a lot of people who are going to read five books this year might even read John of John. They also probably will read a Heated Rivalry. They also will probably read a Sarah J. Moss and I understand that the National Book Award is not going to honor a Sarah J. Moss, and that's fine. And I don't think that they should. But when we talk about a popular book that is critically acclaimed, something like Kin or John of John, to not see it on a list is upsetting to me because I think it is bad for books. As an industry, it is bad for book people. It is saying that that our Oscars is not even willing to acknowledge a book that people love and that the industry loves. It was Amazon's book, so best book of the year so far. This is Kin, it was on Obama's list. It's been it was an Oprah Book Club pick. Like this is what we hope for our books, right? We hope that there is a book that people talk about, and it would be like this year not having like James on the list,

Sara Hildreth 45:29

right?

Traci Thomas 45:30

Right, like James was in 2024 did sort of what Kin is doing. I think James was probably more successful, and we can talk about like black women and like racism and all of these things, but Tayari Jones is she is one of our best. Like I just it is disheartening to me that for whatever reason the judges decided that it wasn't worthy of even making the long list.

Sara Hildreth 45:58

Yes. So okay. So I I think you know in addition to everything, I I think James is such a great book to bring up in this conversation because it was so clearly the book of the year because people were reading it,

Traci Thomas 46:12

right?

Sara Hildreth 46:13

People, not just readers, right? People were talking about it. I think that's key because there are, you know, lots of books that like maybe more people read, but they're not like having these conversations about. And then it was critically acclaimed. I think one of the things that James had that I would say an American marriage also had that Kin doesn't have is that high concept,

Traci Thomas 46:37

that log line, yeah,

Sara Hildreth 46:39

retelling of Huck Finn, you know,

Traci Thomas 46:41

right, right.

Sara Hildreth 46:42

That is not a reason not to put it on the National Book Awards long list by any means. I, I don't know, you know, I'm not, I, I, you know, I'm looking at the list and I, I don't know that, you know, how many of these books have that high concept logline, but I do think that

Traci Thomas 47:01

literally none. Maybe the disappearers.

Sara Hildreth 47:04

That's what I'm looking. I'm like, I don't. I can't tell you in one sentence what any of these books is about. Yeah, I completely agree with you. I I think that it does. It it is clear that sometimes, like the maybe maybe always the judging panels have like kind of their own agenda, and like we were talking about before we hit record, like when the when the mandate is like best book written in English by somebody who lives in the United States, like it's so broad. But I do i I want to look at a list and feel like this is the year in books,

Traci Thomas 47:46

right?

Sara Hildreth 47:46

And I cannot think of the year in books without Kin and John of John. Does John of John qualify?

Traci Thomas 47:52

Yeah, because he was on, I believe, for Suggie Bane.

Sara Hildreth 47:55

Okay, okay

Traci Thomas 47:56

I'm pretty sure he qualifies.

Sara Hildreth 47:58

Okay, with the disappearers, right? And and those are the books that are like I don't know I think for an average reader or somebody who reads even you know 10 books a year or whatever, seeing an awards long list and being like oh I liked that or even like oh I have that on my shelf or I see that in the booking that my friend told me about it, like that you need that because then it gets people excited about the rest. Like even the big names on here,

Traci Thomas 48:31

right?

Sara Hildreth 48:32

Like Dey and by Edwidge Danticat and Python's Kiss, Louise Erdrich, like those are big names, but they're not like the books that you're seeing everywhere.

Traci Thomas 48:44

Okay, I'm actually going to push back that those are big names. What I'm going to say is those are people who have published a lot of books, and the publish and readers who are deep in the publishing space would know. Before I started this podcast, I had never heard of Louise Erdridge or Edwidge Danticat. I had heard of Tayari Jones.

Sara Hildreth 49:01

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 49:01

you know, like I had heard of Marlon James before I started this podcast. I had read a Marlon James book, in fact, which was almost tried to kill me, but I survived. So I do think that, like, I'm not. I'm what I'm suggesting is that, like, because I haven't read these books, I'm not saying that none of these books are good or deserving. Of course, like I'm not saying even Louise Erdrich shouldn't be on here. I know she's won the National Book Award before. She was a she won for the Roundhouse, right?

Sara Hildreth 49:26

I think so. Yeah,

Traci Thomas 49:28

I'm not even like suggesting that she shouldn't be on the list. But what I'm suggesting is like there is a difference between book people like you and I, industry people, and like regular readers. Not to put too fine a point on it, and I was upset about this when it happened. But like Louise Erdrich didn't even make the best 100 books of the year or of the century so far when time when New York Times did it, and that was industry people.

Sara Hildreth 49:53

That's a good point. I was upset about that. But that does show something

Traci Thomas 49:57

that it just shows that. Even within the industry, she might be respected. She's certainly deserving, but she is not a star in this space. And like similarly, I know a lot of people were very excited about Valeria Luiselli, and as am I. I think she's fantastic. We've done her book. Actually, we've done all three of those women's books on this podcast for book club. So, like, I'm. This is not me shitting on them in any regard. It's just saying, like, I think a good if if you were to ask me, and I've said this before about other lists, I think any good list is about 1/3 things that people would know, 1/3 things that people could know, and 1/3 things that you, the curator of the list, are bringing to the table that shows your taste and your interests. So, like when I present you guys with my books on deck each month, there's almost always at least one or two books on there that you're going to be like, "Oh yes, that's right, the new Marlon James is coming. Hopefully, there's going to be a few books where you're like, "Oh, that guy has another book, or "Oh, I feel like I've seen this, and then if I've done my job right, you're going to be like, I didn't even know this book was coming. I didn't even know there was like a new book coming out about the telephone, which there is in October, and I'm very excited. Yeah, that was, and so I feel like I want that from the National Book Award. I want the two or three biggest books of the year, Disappearers and Kin, maybe, or Transcription, maybe, on there. Then you can give me Louise Erdrich and and Edwidge Danticat or whatever, and then you can give me the Morgan Thomas or you know or whatever little random thing. But I think when the lists feel too skewed in any direction, I also would hate a list that was just like Minjin Lee, Marlon James, Edwidge Danticat, Tayari Jones. I'd be like, this is not fun either. Like, why are we only awarding or like acknowledging people who are a big name? But I just feel like if the National Book Award wants to be, for example, like the Booker Prize, which is a meaningful award in the rest of the world, sells a ton of books, has an award ceremony that people like want to attend, has social media that people want to follow. Like they have to think about the scope of the list in relationship to the like they have to have some institutional Gravitas, like you cannot tell me, you cannot draw a straight line between the last 10 National Book Award winners, except for that they're National Book Award winners,

Sara Hildreth 52:31

right?

Traci Thomas 52:32

You know. Whereas, like if you look at a Booker book, you can be like, "Oh yeah, that's a Booker book. Like I don't even read Booker books generally, and I can read a book and be like that's going to be on the list. Like, and similarly, like the reason I'm so good at predicting the Pulitzer is because a Pulitzer has serious institutional integrity, and they have a different process where they have readers, and then they have like their people who work at the Pulitzer who make the decisions, and so there is some connection between year to year. But that's what I love about the Pulitzer,

Sara Hildreth 53:01

right? Right. So I'm looking at the Booker list right now, and I feel like it kind of does the third, a third, a third. I think a little bit better this year. Like it. I mean, like John of John, the Elizabeth Strout. Like I didn't like that, but but like I mean, that's why. I mean, I feel like having. I didn't even really like either of the new Elizabeth Strout or Whistler, but having one of those on the National Book Award list signals to people, oh, I I might be I might like readers of this same with Kin, like oh I might be a reader of this of this award, and then it has books that that were like? Oh yeah, that was on my radar, but I hadn't prioritized it. And then books that I had never heard of, and that does make an experience.

Traci Thomas 53:49

That makes you want to read the books you've never heard of because you're like, right? There were like five New Yorker writers who had books out this year: Rachel Aviv, Adnan Gopal, you had the Pamela Koloff, who is by all accounts like your favorite writer's favorite writer. Like there were some real big names. The nonfiction list this year: zero of the longlisted authors have ever been longlisted for any nonfiction prize at the National Book Award. Only one had been longlisted for anything, and that's Camonghne, and she was longlisted in poetry. So zero out of 10 had even been previous honorees, and that's great. Like that's great. Excited for them, but also that means that we have no like an outside person looking at this list isn't like oh that's the guy from a few years ago. Like there's not there's nothing. Yeah

Sara Hildreth 54:42

yeah okay I yeah I'm getting madder about this the more the more we talk because I do I do wonder if there is a bit of a like okay our industry is dying people aren't reading. Like you know, let's uplift these books that are not getting the play they should be getting.

Traci Thomas 55:06

Yes,

Sara Hildreth 55:07

and I can I can understand if that's kind of a motivation, but it this is going to sound counter to what I'm saying, but it but I'm going to connect them. It reminds me of like the very like elitist Substack people, who I've kind of come around to some of their way of thinking, where they're like, "We need people to be reading the classics. Yeah, and and you know, a lot of them are just like because contemporary books suck, which is just not true. But I think the other part of their reasoning is like because these are books that people talk about and have been talking about for centuries or decades, you know, for thinking modern classics, whatever, because it's the conversation that keeps people reading, which is what you, Traci, I've been saying always that, and that I think is what if we're going to like save the industry, that is what the book awards should be thinking about too. And again, it doesn't mean that that all of a sudden the national book awards list is yesteryear and understory and Sarah J. Maas. It's like, but but like, what are the books that people are reading, and what are the books that are going to facilitate fantastic conversations, not just for people who are like you know curled up reading, thinking about craft all day. Yeah, like so. So yes, I I think that maybe maybe like these decisions are being made for noble reasons because I think there are also like arguments about like everybody just puts their friend on the list or the person they share the agent with, whatever. But maybe they're being made for like very noble reasons, but approached from like such an insider perspective that they can't really achieve what they want to achieve.

Traci Thomas 57:00

Well, and I feel like if the thing is like we want to celebrate books that people aren't talking about or whatever, that's great. But how are you going to get those books in front of people if the list is a bunch of books and nobody's heard about? The list will just go complete under the radar. Yeah, and I feel like that's my my thing is like, I mean, this is like a bigger thing about books. This is way bigger than National Book Award, but I think sometimes book people are so divorced from the rest of culture that they don't understand what makes people want to pick up a book, and it's like it's not it's not being on a National Book Award with a bunch of books nobody's heard of. I mean, I'm a book person again, as you all know. I don't even want to pick up half of these books.

Sara Hildreth 57:42

Yeah, same. Yeah, it did not make me want to read.

Traci Thomas 57:44

It did not make me want to read any of them. I mean, I will read hopefully more of the nonfiction list. And also, like, let's not be totally crazy here. How many books have you read so far this year?

Sara Hildreth 57:58

I don't know, like 150 or something,

Traci Thomas 58:01

and how many have you read from this list?

Sara Hildreth 58:05

One,

Traci Thomas 58:05

and you're a book person. Like I just feel like it's it is it's really it's really alienating to readers. I think I've read like 80 something, 90 books. I've read one and a half on the nonfiction list, and I have mostly read 2026 books this year.

Sara Hildreth 58:24

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 58:24

like I have really been locked in to the to the 2026 beat this year in a way that I am not always. And I mean, I've read a total of three and a half of the books across all the lists.

Sara Hildreth 58:38

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 58:38

only two people this year on any of the lists, have been on the podcast.

Sara Hildreth 58:45

Yeah, that's wild.

Traci Thomas 58:46

In past years, even if they weren't on this year, whatever, like I've had people on the show. I like it's it's a it's a crazy set of lists, and I just don't I don't love it for the for I don't love it for the what it means for books. I love it for the people on the list. Like I'm like this has nothing to actually do with the books themselves. It has to do with like if this is the American Literary Award, if this is our booker is it doing what needs to be done?

Sara Hildreth 59:17

Well, it's also like you said, like to get people reading those other books. They need to see them next to something they know.

Traci Thomas 59:26

They know, and this is true of like the Oscars. Like when the Oscars have like a movie year where like it's like a bunch of like random movies I've never heard of. I'm just like, oh, I'm not gonna do the Oscars this year. Whereas if it's like okay, like I'm more inclined to watch more of the movies if I know a handful of them, right? Like if I'm like, oh, okay, I saw those two. Let me see what's what's better. And also, like when there's big celebrities, I'm like, okay, well, let me go see these other movies to see if like Leonardo DiCaprio really deserved this for the Revenant. He didn't.

Sara Hildreth 59:57

Do you think that? They like that these awards are thrown off because there are so many people on Bookstagram who are like, I'm going to read this whole list and like you know read the whole list in like two weeks and all the checkoffs and they're like all people are doing it the reading list but they have to get sales numbers and

Traci Thomas 1:00:20

yeah

Sara Hildreth 1:00:20

they have to see beyond that, right?

Traci Thomas 1:00:22

I mean, I would love to know what the sales are in the week after the announcement.

Sara Hildreth 1:00:28

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 1:00:29

I would be curious to know what they are in general, and I would be curious to know over different years if there are bumps depending on what's on the list, like how the trickle down would actually work.

Sara Hildreth 1:00:40

Yeah

Traci Thomas 1:00:41

I don't even think people know about the National Book Award long list announcement.

Sara Hildreth 1:00:45

No, yeah,

Traci Thomas 1:00:46

people do know about the Pulitzer. I I know the Pulitzer moves books. I know the Booker moves books. Maybe not in the United States, but I know it's a big, big, big deal around the world, like a life changing sort of deal for for people. I just I don't know.

Sara Hildreth 1:01:05

Do you think that the National Book Awards should function like the Oscars, where like everybody, like card carrying members?

Traci Thomas 1:01:12

I was actually just talking about this yesterday with a friend. I part of me does feel like it would be more fun, but the problem

Sara Hildreth 1:01:21

maybe that should exist as its own separate its own award.

Traci Thomas 1:01:24

Yeah, like the book industry award. Like, because I think that's like what the book critic circle does.

Sara Hildreth 1:01:30

Yes,

Traci Thomas 1:01:31

they have like it's like it's like a card carrying member situation. I would love to know what that would look like. It would be hard because you probably have like people at publishers like just like rooting for their own book or like

Sara Hildreth 1:01:43

right, but that's how it works for the Oscars too, right?

Traci Thomas 1:01:47

Yeah, you're right. But I wonder if it's like you'd have to have they probably what they would have to do is like how they do it at the Oscars, where you'd have like a large nominating committee, maybe like 50 people, but then you're asking 50 people to read like 500 books, whereas like in the Oscars, it's just not quite as many movies.

Sara Hildreth 1:02:05

Yeah, it's a movie. It's you know three hours

Traci Thomas 1:02:07

exactly.

Sara Hildreth 1:02:08

Yeah

Traci Thomas 1:02:09

then you'd have to once you had the nominees, then you could open it up to the broader voting public. I don't know. I I do think there's something. I think like the Center for Fiction does it in reverse. The Center for Fiction has like a lot of people for their first novel prize who are like early readers, and they read like seven or so of the books

Sara Hildreth 1:02:29

like a lot of people.

Traci Thomas 1:02:30

Yeah, like 100 people or something, and then they have like three judges or five judges.

Sara Hildreth 1:02:35

So I read for the Aspen Words Prize, which I feel like has really gone downhill, Unfortunately, but I feel like the year I read for it, it was an exceptional list. But there were three of us who were readers, and we read, and for that, we were supposed to rate each book based on its like overall like literary merit, and they kind of define that as like, will this book stand the test of time? Which I think is like an you know all of these little caveats you can give or descriptors you can give can be helpful, and then was the book like how well or you know did it address a vital social issue, and because that's the meaning of that, yeah. And you know, you can think whatever you want about that mandate, and I think it can be really hit or miss. But those two things were really helpful to keep in mind as I was reading, and then we each each reader submitted our list of 20 top 20 books ranked, along with our like score, and then they just like looked at the lists and put together the top I think it was 10 or 12 or or something. If there were questions like if somebody like had ranked it really low and somebody high, they did like reach out and ask us like you know

Traci Thomas 1:04:06

yeah

Sara Hildreth 1:04:06

our opinions. Then it was a different jury committee who read those 20 books and chose the short list and the the winner. I I don't know if that's like a good, but like feel like a tiered system can be beneficial. Yeah, I also just feel like you know having some like best book, like I don't know, maybe the national book where it should be like meaning will it stand the test of time? Like I think that's a great question, right?

Traci Thomas 1:04:35

Right. They don't have like I don't think they have any real like anything like that discerns it for any reason, which I again, I just I think it's tricky. I think it's tricky. When I was a judge for the LA Times Book Prize, I had a category current interest, so they did not give us a lot of things. They were just like current interest go. But what we could do is we actually built our own list. So we asked for the books that we wanted to read for the prize. Oh, cool! And they sentenced us. There was no submissions from the publishers, which meant that like you could read more widely, and also that like the list was sort of shaped by the judges. I'm an overachiever, so of our list of like 140 books, I think that I requested 100 of them because I was like, I don't want to miss anything. But for me, I just kept saying, "Well, is this currently interesting? Like, I just kept using the title of the category as like that was my own personal thing. I'm like, "Is this currently interesting? Does this feel like current? It is interesting to the current moment. Does it feel current? Am I interest? I just kept like finding different versions of current interest to use, and like that was like the fights that we would have, and the thing I'd be like, well, it's a good book, but like, does it feel current right now to 2023? Does it feel like this is this moment? If we're putting together a list of five books, is a book about you know dogs? What we want to talk about when we could be doing a book about climate change, like or whatever. But I do think, like I don't know, I I do think the National Book Award is too broad because also they don't have categories besides like really big ones and like poetry. Like poetry is a category; it's not a genre. Like it could you know like nonfiction. You have so many options for what is nonfiction. And and the last two years, the National Book Award has been very interested in memoir. And in previous years, like the two preceding years, much less. I think in like 2024 there were only two, and last year there were seven or eight. This year there were six or so. I say or so because some books are sort of like have memoir elements, and it's hard to know just by looking at it exactly what's going on in there. But last year it was so memoir personal writing heavy, and I did not finish the list for obvious reasons.

Sara Hildreth 1:06:57

I I will also add that at one point, I was talking with a somebody who was on a National Book Award judging panel, and I really got the sense from our conversation that in their year, the book that they chose to award was very much a like lifetime achievement type of thing, and I wonder, like when I look at this year's list, I see that's a little bit of what I see is like some lifetime achievementy selections, like you said, industry focused, not wide, and then so I-I mean, I just people can like skew. Have you have you heard of this book, Search by Michelle Huneven?

Traci Thomas 1:07:50

No,

Sara Hildreth 1:07:52

it is. It sounds like the most boring book in the world. It's fiction, but it is about a a woman who like begrudgingly joins a search committee for her Unitarian Universalist Church's new minister.

Traci Thomas 1:08:06

Okay,

Sara Hildreth 1:08:07

but it reads like a thriller, Traci, because this one person on the committee just slowly like bends everyone to her will, just like chips away at their will to live. Nobody wants to have these conversations anymore, and they just, you know, they they all have to just like fall in line. And I think it is such a perfect depiction of any type of committee. Yeah, and that is sometimes what I imagine some of these awards committees are. Is just like if you have one person who is just like the holdout, the like I am not, you know. Then what do you do? And then sometimes I think that's why you end up with lists that are like, this is so confusing.

Traci Thomas 1:08:51

Do you know what this just reminded me of? You are saying it reminds me of one of my absolute favorite things that happens in the world, which you have been close witness to for me is Conclave, yes, the book, and also our great Katniss Evergreen American Pope, Hunger Games Pope. No, I think you're right. I think I think it can be very much that. I think I just think that the panels, the judges have agendas no matter what, and I think that what some institutions are able to do is protect against the agendas in some regard with the mandate or the sort of call to action that they give them, and I think the National Book Award is particularly susceptible to the judge's agenda in a way that the Booker is not. Because again, for people who have are newish here, talked to Kylie Reed, who was a judge last year about this for the Booker? You have to read the book that wins and the entire shortlist three full times. So even if you have an agenda and you're like, my friend Sarah wrote a book and I really want it to win. If Sarah's book is telling you have a secret for 75 pages the third time through, I. Just don't think you're gonna be able to convince people that Sarah's book is good enough. Yeah, like there is the award itself, the requirements of doing the award force you to pick something that is a certain kind of book, and it protects the Booker Prize from agendas in some regard.

Sara Hildreth 1:10:20

Well, and like the Pulitzer, we saw that protection.

Traci Thomas 1:10:22

Yes,

Sara Hildreth 1:10:23

in play. Yes, when James won.

Traci Thomas 1:10:25

Yes, yeah, that was the same trip as the conclave big week.

Sara Hildreth 1:10:29

Yeah, big week for us. Yeah, where there clearly was a like under the radar book agenda, and the Pulitzer committee was like, people, we have a reputation to protect. People are going to be looking back on this in 20 years and being like

Traci Thomas 1:10:45

mice, 1961, like again again, and it's the Pulitzer. It's correct, and I think that that is the thing. The National Book Award does not have the same kind of obsession with themselves that I think they need. The Pulitzer would never let Merv Emray bring them down. Do you know what I mean? Like they're like we're the fucking Pulitzer.

Sara Hildreth 1:11:12

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 1:11:12

I don't care. You guys are a great group of judges, but like it's James.

Sara Hildreth 1:11:18

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 1:11:19

it's been James. It's gonna be James. Okay, like I'm so sorry. You guys can have mice. You guys can have your three finalists, but you're gonna have a fourth finalist, and that's gonna be the winner. And that's it. Period. Like, period. We don't fucking care. And I sometimes wish the National Book Award had that same energy of like

Sara Hildreth 1:11:40

totally

Traci Thomas 1:11:41

of like we love the list.

Sara Hildreth 1:11:42

We don't we don't even award it some year because none of you deserve it.

Traci Thomas 1:11:46

We love the list. We love you guys. Thank you for being judges. And also, I'm gonna let you finish. But Kin was one of the best books of the year. Like it has to be here. Like it has to be here.

Sara Hildreth 1:11:56

Yeah,

Traci Thomas 1:11:57

that's it, guys. We're done. We're done. We gotta go. We went way over. We gotta go. Good luck to my editor.

Sara Hildreth 1:12:02

Go read Kin.

Traci Thomas 1:12:03

Go read Kin. Go read The Disappearers. Go read the long list. You guys can tell us why we're idiots, and all these books are the most deserving books in the history of the world.

Sara Hildreth 1:12:13

Would love to know. Actually, without having to read the book.

Traci Thomas 1:12:14

Yeah, because I'm I'm hearing some chatter about some of these books for people who've read them that are like, wait, what?

Sara Hildreth 1:12:21

I need to know.

Traci Thomas 1:12:22

I'll tell you more. Okay. Everybody, if you're listening to this, you're paid subscriber of Sarah and I already. We love you. We thank you. If you are paid subscriber of one of us and not the other, you should make it a twofer. But you know, we get it. If you can't, if you don't want to become a free one, that's fine too. Just like if you're here, we love you and we thank you. We

Sara Hildreth 1:12:43

We love you and we thank you. And Traci, I love you and thank you. And I love you for talking books with me. I really needed this. This was fun.

Traci Thomas 1:12:49

Me too. And everyone else, we will see you in the stacks slash in the Fiction Matters pages.

Previous
Previous

Unabridged: The Death of Nonfiction with Tajja Isen

Next
Next

Unabridged: Reading Translated Literature with Martha Adams